System and Method for Fabricating Composite Parts

ABSTRACT

The present application is directed to systems for controlling the direction of thermal expansion of a composite part during thermal processing. The systems may comprise at least one guiding mechanism capable of being attached to a surface of a tool for fabricating composites and at least one moveable composite insert capable of being attached to a composite part. The moveable composite insert has an opening for receiving the at least one guiding mechanism. The opening is capable of controlling movement of the at least one moveable composite insert in a desired direction during thermal expansion of the composite part, when the guiding mechanism is received by the opening. Methods for controlling the direction of thermal expansion of a composite part during thermal processing are also disclosed.

This application is a divisional of application Ser. No. 11/251,156, filed Oct. 13, 2005, status Allowed.

BACKGROUND OF THE DISCLOSURE

The present application relates to systems and methods for fabricating composites.

Composites have a variety of applications in a broad range of industries, such as aircraft manufacturing, boat hull fabrication, automobile body fabrication, as well as others. The fabrication of a composite often involves formulation of individual composite parts and the alignment and bonding together of those composite parts into a composite assembly. During this fabrication process, the composite is subjected to a number of high temperature curing and bonding operations. Alignment tolerances between the composite parts during the bonding operations can be narrow, for example, on the order of about 0.005 inch. Maintaining proper alignment within such narrow tolerances can be difficult due to thermal expansion and contraction of the composite parts and the tooling apparatus used to form the parts. This is because thermal expansion may cause movement of the composite parts relative to one another and/or the tooling apparatus during the thermal cycles of the bonding and curing operations. The problem is exacerbated where the parts and/or the tooling apparatuses are made from materials having differing coefficients of thermal expansion (CTE), which cause the parts and/or tooling apparatus to expand and contract at different rates.

Failure to maintain alignment within the desired tolerances can cause undesirable structural defects, such as voids or stress risers in the bond lines of the composite parts. These defects may require repair or scrapping of the composite parts altogether, which can be costly.

In the past, the problem of maintaining proper alignment of composite parts of an assembly during thermal processing has been dealt with by installing slotted bushings in the surface of the tooling apparatus used to fabricate the assembly. The composite parts are held in place on the surface of the tooling apparatus using pins inserted into the slots of the bushings. The pins are attached to the composite parts by either cutting mating holes in the wet composite parts through which the pins can be inserted and then curing the pins directly into the composite parts, or by installing transfer pins in the bushings and then back-drilling the hole in the composite part after it is cured. The pins attached to the composite parts move back and forth in the bushings to allow for thermal expansion and contraction of the composite parts during processing.

However, there are certain problems with the above-described methods. For example, the slots in the bushings often fill with resin, which is used to form the composites, and become useless. In cases where back-drilling is employed, the resulting holes in the composites are not always positioned accurately. Further, during multi-step bonding operations, the pins bear upon the sidewalls of the holes in the composites, often causing the mating holes by which the pins are held in the composite parts to become oversized. The oversized mating holes may allow the pins to become improperly positioned in the composite parts, which may result in failure to maintain the proper tolerances for producing an acceptable composite assembly.

SUMMARY OF THE DISCLOSURE

The above-mentioned drawbacks associated with existing systems and methods for fabricating composite parts are addressed by embodiments of the present disclosure, which will be understood by reading and studying the following specification.

One embodiment of the present application is directed to a system for controlling the direction of thermal expansion of a composite part during thermal processing. The system comprises at least one guiding mechanism capable of being attached to a surface of a tool for fabricating composites. The system further comprises at least one moveable composite insert capable of being attached to a composite part and having an opening for receiving the at least one guiding mechanism. The opening has a configuration capable of controlling movement of the composite insert in a controlled manner when the guiding mechanism is received by the opening.

Another embodiment of the present application is directed to an aircraft composite part comprising a composite material and one or more composite inserts attached to the composite material. The one or more composite inserts comprise a first major surface, an opposing second major surface, an outer perimeter edge formed between the first and second major surfaces and an opening formed through the composite insert between the first and second major surfaces.

Another embodiment of the present application is directed to a method for fabricating a composite part. The method comprises attaching at least one stationary composite insert at one or more stationary positions of the composite part and attaching at least one moveable composite insert at one or more moveable positions of the composite part. The at least one stationary composite insert allows the composite part to be held substantially stationary relative to the surface of the tool at the one or more stationary positions of the composite part, and the at least one moveable composite insert allows the composite part to move in a controlled manner at the one or more moveable positions of the composite part.

Yet another embodiment of the present application is directed to a method for fabricating an aircraft composite part on the surface of a tool. The method comprises attaching at least one stationary composite insert at one or more stationary positions of the aircraft composite part, and attaching at least one moveable composite insert at one or more moveable positions of the aircraft composite part. The at least one stationary composite insert allows the aircraft composite part to be held substantially stationary relative to the surface of the tool at the one or more stationary positions of the aircraft composite part, and the at least one moveable composite insert allows the aircraft composite part to move in a controlled manner at the one or more moveable positions of the aircraft composite part.

These and other embodiments of the present application will be discussed more fully in the detailed description. The features, functions, and advantages can be achieved independently in various embodiments of the claimed disclosure, or may be combined in yet other embodiments.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and constitute a part of this specification, illustrate exemplary embodiments of the disclosure and, together with the written description, serve to explain the principles of the disclosure.

In the drawings:

FIG. 1 is a three-dimensional view illustrating top and side surfaces of a composite part, the composite part being positioned relative to the surface of a tool using a system comprising a moveable assembly and stationary assembly, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIG. 2 is a three-dimensional view illustrating top and side surfaces of the tool illustrated in FIG. 1, showing an exploded view of moveable and stationary assemblies, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIGS. 3A to 3E are three-dimensional and cross sectional views illustrating alignment pin bushings, according to various embodiments of the present application.

FIGS. 4A to 4F are three-dimensional views illustrating alignment pins, according to various embodiments of the present application.

FIGS. 5A to 5C are three-dimensional and topside views illustrating moveable composite inserts, according to various embodiments of the present application.

FIG. 6 is a cross-sectional view of a moveable assembly attached to a composite part, which is supported on the surface of a tool, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIG. 7 is a topside view of an alignment pin positioned within an opening of a moveable composite insert, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIGS. 8A and 8B are three-dimensional views illustrating straight pins, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIG. 9 is a magnified three-dimensional view of a moveable assembly similar to that shown in FIG. 1, where the alignment pin has been replaced by a straight pin, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIG. 10 is an exploded view of a stationary assembly, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIG. 11 is a three-dimensional view of a stationary composite insert, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIG. 12 is a topside view of a composite part having stationary and moveable assemblies positioned therein, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIG. 13 is a cross-sectional view of a composite part having stationary and moveable assemblies positioned therein, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIG. 14 is a three-dimensional view of two composite parts positioned relative to one another using stationary and moveable assemblies, according to one embodiment of the present application.

FIG. 15 is a cross sectional view of a moveable assembly where the bushing is inserted into a composite part, rather than into the surface of the tool, according to one embodiment of the present application.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE DISCLOSURE

In the following detailed description, reference is made to the accompanying drawings that form a part thereof, and in which is shown by way of illustration specific exemplary embodiments in which the disclosure may be practiced. These embodiments are described in sufficient detail to enable those skilled in the art to practice the disclosure invention, and it is to be understood that modifications to the various disclosed embodiments may be made, and other embodiments may be utilized, without departing from the spirit and scope of the present disclosure. The following detailed description is, therefore, not to be taken in a limiting sense.

The present application is generally related to controlling the direction of thermal expansion of a composite part during thermal processing. FIG. 1 illustrates a composite part 2 supported on the surface of a tool 4. While composite part 2 is illustrated as a simple flat panel laminate, the systems and methods of the present application may be used to fabricate composites of any shape and size, including, for example, composites having complex shapes and composite assemblies having multiple composite parts. Composite part 2 may be a part for use in any industry. For example, composite part 2 may be an aircraft composite part, a boat hull composite part, an automobile composite part, or other composite part. In addition, the concepts of the present application are not limited to use with tool 4, as illustrated in FIG. 1, but could be employed with any suitable tool used in bonding, curing or other thermal processes involved in the fabrication of composites, including, for example, molds, bond jigs, and assembly jigs.

In one embodiment, the direction of thermal expansion of a composite part may be controlled with a system comprising one or more moveable assemblies and/or one or more stationary assemblies. For example, in the embodiment of FIG. 1, thermal expansion of composite part 2 may be controlled relative to the surface of tool 4 using a system comprising a moveable assembly 5 and stationary assembly 7. Moveable assembly 5 guides composite part 2 so that composite part 2 moves in a desired direction of thermal expansion relative to the surface of tool 4 at moveable position 6. Stationary assembly 7 holds composite part 2 substantially stationary relative to the surface of tool 4 at stationary position 8 of composite part 2.

An exploded view of one embodiment of moveable and stationary assemblies 5 and 7 is shown in FIG. 2. In the FIG. 2 embodiment, moveable assembly 5 comprises alignment pin bushing 12, alignment pin 14 and moveable composite insert 16. Moveable composite insert 16 has an opening 16 a, better illustrated in FIG. 5A, for receiving alignment pin 14. Opening 16 a has a configuration capable of controlling movement of moveable composite insert 16 in a controlled manner when alignment pin 14 is received by opening 16 a. Alignment pin 14 may be attached to the surface of tool 4 via alignment pin bushing 12. In this manner, alignment pin 14 may act as a guiding mechanism for guiding moveable composite insert 16 relative to the surface of tool 4.

In the embodiment of FIG. 2, stationary assembly 7 comprises a stationary pin bushing 18, a stationary pin 20 and a stationary composite insert 22. As illustrated in FIG. 2, stationary pin 20 may extend through opening 22 a of stationary composite insert 22 and into stationary pin bushing 18, which in turn may be inserted into hole 17 in the surface of tool 4. Stationary pin 20 has a cross section having approximately the same dimensions as opening 22 a in stationary composite insert 22, so that stationary composite insert 22 fits snugly around stationary pin 20, and is thereby held substantially stationary relative to the surface of tool 4.

The one or more moveable assemblies and one or more stationary assemblies are not limited to the embodiment illustrated in FIG. 2. For example, the guiding mechanism of the moveable assembly is not limited to alignment pin 14. Rather, any suitable means for guiding moveable composite insert 16 relative to the surface of tool 4 may be employed, such as, for example, straight pin 32, as illustrated in FIG. 9 and described in greater detail below. In another embodiment, alignment pin 14 and stationary pin 20 can be inserted directly into holes in the surface of tool 4, rather than employing alignment pin bushing 12 and stationary pin bushing 18. Other variations of the above embodiments would be readily apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art, and fall within the scope of the present application.

Moveable composite insert 16 and stationary composite insert 22 may be attached to composite part 2 by any suitable means. In one embodiment, moveable composite insert 16 and stationary composite insert 22 may be attached by curing the inserts in place in composite part 2, as will be discussed in detail below.

As discussed above, opening 16 a has a configuration capable of controlling movement of moveable composite insert 16 in a controlled manner. For example, in one embodiment, opening 16 a may control movement of moveable composite insert 16 in a desired direction relative to stationary position 8 and/or relative to the surface of tool 4. The desired direction may be any suitable direction, as will be discussed in greater detail below. In one embodiment, the desired direction may be along the major axis of thermal expansion. The major axis of thermal expansion is generally defined as an axis along which the greatest thermal expansion occurs for a given change in temperature. As is well known in the art, the greatest thermal expansion will generally occur along the longest dimension, or longitudinal axis, of a composite part. For example, in the embodiment of FIG. 1, thermal expansion may be guided in the direction of arrow 10 relative to stationary position 8, along the longitudinal axis z of composite part 2.

The desired direction of thermal expansion relative to stationary position 8 may be the same or different than the desired direction of thermal expansion relative to the surface of tool 4, depending on whether the surface of tool 4 has a larger or smaller CTE than the CTE of composite part 2. If, for example, the surface of tool 4 has a smaller CTE than the material of composite part 2 in FIG. 1, the direction of thermal expansion of composite part 2 relative to the surface of tool 4 will also be in the direction of arrow 10. However, if the surface of tool 4 has a larger CTE than the material of composite part 2, than the direction of thermal expansion of composite part 2 relative to the surface of tool 4 may be in the opposite direction of arrow 10.

While FIG. 1 illustrates a single moveable assembly 5 and a single stationary assembly 7 at either end of composite part 2, other embodiments may employ a plurality of moveable assemblies and/or a plurality of stationary assemblies. As will be discussed in greater detail below, the at least one moveable assembly and the at least one stationary assembly may be arranged in any suitable configuration, depending on the shape and size of a particular composite part, in order to achieve the desired direction of thermal expansion.

FIG. 2 further illustrates an excess part line 26, which is an outline of composite part 2 as it appears during processing, similarly as shown in FIG. 1. Net part line 24 is an outline of the finished composite part 2 after processing is complete. In one embodiment, stationary composite insert 22 and moveable composite insert 16 may be placed in the excess composite part 2, or offal, which is the portion of the composite between the net part line 24 and the excess part line 26. After processing is complete, composite part 2 may be trimmed to remove the offal, including the stationary and moveable composite inserts.

In other embodiments, it may be desirable to place composite inserts 16 and 22 within net part line 24, so they are attached to the portion of composite part 2 which will comprise the finished part. Thus, composite inserts 16 and 22 may be removed from finished composite part 2 after processing is complete, or alternatively, the composite inserts may remain in finished composite part 2.

A more detailed description of various embodiments of moveable assembly 5 and stationary assembly 7 will now be provided.

FIGS. 3A and 3B illustrate one embodiment of an alignment pin bushing 12 comprising a liner having an outer surface 12 a and an inner surface 12 b formed concentrically around a central longitudinal axis 12 c. Inner surface 12 b defines the dimensions of an aperture 12 d, which is also formed along the central longitudinal axis 12 c.

In one embodiment, aperture 12 d has a non-circular cross section formed in a plane intersecting the central longitudinal axis 12 c at right angles. For example, aperture 12 d may have a cross section having a shape defined by the outer most perimeter of a concentric, overlapping polygon and circle. The polygon may be any suitable polygon, such as a triangle, square, pentagon, hexagon, heptagon, or octagon.

FIGS. 3A and 3B illustrate one such embodiment where the polygon is a square. The sides of the square intersect the circle so that the outer most perimeter of the concentric overlapping polygon and circle form the cross-sectional shape of aperture 12 d, shown in FIG. 3B. Aperture 12 d comprises cylindrically shaped surface portions 12 e and grooved surface portions 12 f. Cylindrically shaped surface portions 12 e correspond to portions of the circle which intersect with, and lie outside of, the polygon; and grooved surface portions 12 f correspond to portions of the square, including vertices and side portions, which intersect with, and lie outside of, the circle. As shown in FIGS. 3A and B, this arrangement results in the inner surface 12 b having a plurality of alternating cylindrically shaped surface portions 12 e and grooved surface portions 12 f. Grooved surface portions 12 f run longitudinally along inner surface 12 b in parallel with central longitudinal axis 12 c.

The cylindrically shaped surface portions and the grooved surface portions are arranged so that the aperture is capable of accepting both a pin having a shank with a circular cross section in frictional slip fit with the cylindrically shaped surface portions 12 e, as well as a pin having a shank with a noncircular cross section, such as a square, in frictional slip fit with the grooved surface portions 12 f of inner surface 12 b. Examples of pins with noncircular and circular cross sections are illustrated in FIG. 4 and FIG. 8, respectively, which will be described in greater detail below.

The relative dimensions of aperture 12 d and the circular and noncircular shanks of the corresponding pins may be adjusted to maintain the desired degree of precision in positioning the guiding mechanism. FIG. 3B illustrates a width W_(pa) and a diameter D_(ca) of the aperture 12 d, which correspond to a width, W_(s), of shank 14 a in FIG. 4B and a diameter D_(s), of shank 32 a in FIG. 8B. In embodiments where high alignment tolerances of composite parts in subsequent bonding processes is desired, the relative sizes of these dimensions may be adjusted to achieve the desired tolerances. In one embodiment, W_(pa) may be formed to be only slightly larger than W_(s), so that a high tolerance slip fit is achieved. For example, W_(pa) may be less than about 0.01 inches larger than W_(s). In another exemplary embodiment, W_(pa) may be about 0.001 to about 0.0001 inches larger than W_(s). Similar tolerances may apply to the relative sizes of D_(ca) and D_(s).

Aperture 12 d is not limited to the shape illustrated in FIGS. 3A and 3B, but may be any suitable noncircular shape which allows the head of alignment pin 14 to be fixed in a desired direction, as will be discussed in greater detail below. In certain embodiments, aperture 12 d may have a cross section which has the shape of a triangle, square, or other polygon shape. For example, an embodiment of a bushing with a square cross section is illustrated in FIG. 3C. In yet other embodiments, aperture 12 d may have only one or two cylindrically shaped surface portions 12 e and one or two grooved surface portions 12 f which run longitudinally along the inner surface 12 b in parallel with central longitudinal axis 12 c. For example, a cross sectional view of a bushing with a single groove is illustrated in FIG. 3D. Other suitable shapes would be readily apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art and are within the scope of the present application.

As illustrated in FIG. 3A, alignment pin bushing 12 also may include an optional groove 12 g positioned in the inner surface 12 b at one end of aperture 12 d. Groove 12 g is shaped to accept an O-ring, such as the O-ring 14 e positioned around the shank 14 a of alignment pin 14 illustrated in FIG. 4C.

Alignment pin bushing 12 may be formed by any suitable process. For example, in one embodiment, grooved surface portions 12 f are formed by machining the cylindrically shaped inner surface of a standard bushing. One example of a suitable machining technique for forming grooved surface portions 12 f is electric discharge machining (EDM). In this embodiment, an anode having the desired dimensions may be employed to burn grooved surface portions into the cylindrical inner surface of a bushing. For example, a square anode may be used to form the four grooved surface portions 12 f illustrated in the embodiment of FIG. 3B. In other embodiments, bushings which have any number of grooves may be formed. For example, bushings which have six or eight grooved surface portions may be formed using hexagon or octagon shaped anodes.

Alignment pin bushing 12 may be made from any suitable material. Examples of suitable materials include stainless steel, spring steel, ceramics, carbon and Teflon.

Referring back to FIG. 2, the orientation of the alignment pin bushing 12 in the surface of the tool 4 may determine the orientation of the head 14 b of alignment pin 14, which in turn determines the orientation of opening 16 a of the moveable insert, as will be discussed in greater detail below. The alignment pin bushing may be fixed in the desired orientation by any suitable means. In certain embodiments, outside surface 12 a is configured so as to fix the orientation of the alignment pin bushing in tool 4. For example, in the embodiment illustrated in FIG. 3A, a roll-pinned groove 12 h is formed along outside surface 12 a of alignment pin bushing 12. A corresponding groove (not shown) is also formed in hole 11 of tool 4, illustrated in FIG. 2. Alignment pin bushing 12 may then be fixed in the surface of tool 4 in the desired orientation by inserting pin 13, illustrated in FIG. 6, in the aperture formed by aligning the groove in hole 11 with roll-pinned groove 12 h. In an alternative embodiment, outside surface 12 a is provided with a knurled finish, which allows alignment pin bushing 12 to maintain the correct orientation by friction fit. One example of a knurled finish is illustrated in FIG. 3E, which shows knurled portions 12 i. Other suitable knurled finishes may also be employed. Techniques for roll pinning and for providing knurled surfaces are well known in the art.

FIGS. 4A to 4C illustrate one embodiment of alignment pin 14, which comprises a head 14 b and a shank 14 a, which extends from head 14 b. Head 14 b has a longitudinal axis x which is perpendicular to a longitudinal axis y of shank 14 a. Shank 14 a has a non-circular cross section, where the cross section is defined by a plane intersecting longitudinal axis y of shank 14 a at right angles. In the embodiment shown in FIG. 4A, shank 14 a has a square cross section. The square cross section allows shank 14 a to be inserted into alignment pin bushing 12 in a frictional slip fit with grooved surface portions 12 f, which prevents shank 14 a from rotating in aperture 12 d, thereby allowing longitudinal axis x of head 14 b to be fixed in a desired direction. In other embodiments, the cross section of shank 14 a may have any suitable noncircular shape which will allow it to be fixed in the desired position in a bushing having an aperture capable of accepting a shank of that particular shape. For example, the cross section of shank 14 a may have a polygon shape other than a square, such as a hexagon or an octagon shape, in which case alignment pin bushing 12 may have an aperture shaped so as to be capable of respectively accepting a shank with a hexagon or octagon shaped cross section.

In some embodiments, a groove 14 c is formed around the base of shank 14 a, adjacent to head 14 b, for accepting an O-ring. An O-ring 14 e may be positioned around shank 14 a in groove 14 c, as illustrated in FIG. 4C. When alignment pin 14 is inserted into aperture 12 d of alignment pin bushing 12, as illustrated in FIG. 6, the O-ring 14 e rests in O-ring groove 12 g and helps to prevent, or reduce the amount of resin which runs down into aperture 12 d during processing. O-ring 14 e may be made of any suitable material which has the desired elasticity, tolerance to temperature, and compatibility with the particular resin of the composite being processed. In one exemplary embodiment, O-ring 14 e may comprise rubber, such as a neoprene rubber.

In the embodiment illustrated in FIG. 4B, a hole 14 d is positioned in the top of head 14 b. The inner surface of hole 14 d may be threaded. This allows a device, such as a slide hammer, to be screwed into hole 14 d and used to remove alignment pin 14 from alignment pin bushing 12. In this way, alignment pin 14 may be more easily removed in situations where it becomes lodged in alignment pin bushing 12, such as where resin manages to flow past O-ring 14 e during processing and causes alignment pin 14 to stick.

In the embodiment illustrated in FIG. 4A, the head 14 b of alignment pin 14 is long and narrow, and extends out on opposite sides of shank 14 a, so that alignment pin 14 has a “T” shape. As illustrated in the embodiment of FIG. 5C, the shape of head 14 b has a length, L_(h), and a width, W_(h), which allows head 14 b to act as a guide to aid in properly aligning opening 16 a of moveable composite insert 16, as mentioned above. The ratio of L_(h) to W_(h) may be any suitable ratio. In one embodiment, the ratio of L_(h) to W_(h) may be greater than about 1.5:1, such as, for example, about 2:1 to about 4:1.

In other embodiments, head 14 b may have any suitable size or shape which will provide the necessary alignment of moveable composite insert 16. For example, in one embodiment illustrated in FIG. 4D, the length, L_(h), of head 14 b may be the same as the width, W_(s), of shank 14 a, so that the head does not extend from the sides of shank 14 a. In another embodiment, head 14 b only extends from one side of shank 14 a, so as to form a pin illustrated in FIG. 4E.

In yet another embodiment, two pins may be used to provide the desired alignment of moveable composite insert 16. FIG. 4F illustrates one such embodiment, where two cylindrical alignment pins 14, which are separated by a small distance, are employed to provide the desired alignment along a desired axis of expansion z_(e). Still other means for aligning moveable composite insert 16 along the desired axis of expansion would be readily apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art, and fall with in the scope of the present application.

Alignment pin 14 may be made from any suitable material using any suitable machining method. Examples of suitable materials include stainless steel, spring steel, ceramics, carbon and Teflon. Suitable machining methods are well known in the art.

FIGS. 5A to 5C illustrate various exemplary embodiments of a moveable composite insert. As shown in FIG. 5A, moveable composite insert 16 comprises a first major surface 16 e, an opposing second major surface 16 f (illustrated in FIG. 6), and an outer perimeter edge 16 g formed between first and second major surfaces 16 e and 16 f. An opening 16 a is formed through moveable composite insert 16. In one embodiment, as illustrated in FIG. 5A, the longitudinal axis z_(o) of opening 16 a runs along a central axis z_(m) of moveable composite insert 16. In other embodiments, z_(o) may be offset from z_(m).

The size and shape of opening 16 a are chosen to allow opening 16 a to receive at least one guiding mechanism, such as alignment pin 14, straight pin 32, or some other guiding mechanism, so that opening 16 a is capable of controlling movement of movable composite insert 16 in a desired direction when the guiding mechanism is received by opening 16 a. Referring to FIG. 5C, opening 16 a has a length, L_(o), which is sufficient to allow the moveable composite insert 16 to move back and forth on the guiding mechanism along the length of opening 16 a when the guiding mechanism is positioned within opening 16 a. In one embodiment, the width, W_(o), of opening 16 a is sized relative to the guiding mechanism so that movement of the moveable composite insert 16 is substantially limited in at least one direction when the guiding mechanism is positioned within opening 16 a.

FIG. 7 illustrates another exemplary embodiment employing alignment pin 14 as the guiding mechanism positioned within opening 16 a of moveable composite insert 16. Opening 16 a accepts head 14 b of alignment pin 14. Opening 16 a has a length L_(o) which is greater than length L_(h) of head 14 b, so as to allow moveable composite insert 16 to move back and forth on head 14 b along the length of opening 16 a.

In one embodiment, the width, W_(o) of opening 16 a may be only slightly larger than, width W_(h) of head 14 b, so that substantially no movement of head 14 b occurs in the direction of width W_(o) of opening 16 a, thereby substantially confining the relative movement of head 14 b and moveable composite insert 16 to a back and forth movement along longitudinal axis z_(o) when head 14 b is positioned within opening 16 a. In other embodiments, the relative dimensions W_(o) and W_(h) may be adjusted to maintain the desired degree of precision in controlling movement of the moveable composite insert in a desired direction in subsequent bonding processes. For example, in embodiments where high alignment tolerances of composite parts in subsequent bonding is desired, the relative sizes, of these dimensions may be adjusted to achieve a high tolerance slip fit arrangement. For example, W_(o) may be less than about 0.01 inches larger than W_(h). In another exemplary embodiment, W_(o) may be about 0.001 to about 0.0001 inches larger than W_(h).

In one embodiment, the opening is substantially elongated, so that length L_(o) of opening 16 a is substantially greater than width W_(o). For example, the ratio of L_(o):W_(o) may be two or greater. In one embodiment, the ratio of L_(o):W_(o) may be three or greater, such that opening 16 a forms a slot. In other embodiments, opening 16 a may have any suitable shape which allows the desired movement of moveable composite insert 16.

In certain embodiments, as illustrated in FIGS. 5A to 5C, a plurality of apertures 16 b are formed through moveable composite insert 16. Apertures 16 b may be formed between opening 16 a and outer perimeter edge 16 g, and may enhance bonding with the composite, as will be further described below. Apertures 16 b may be formed in any desired configuration which will provide the necessary physical bond between the composite part 2 and moveable composite insert 16 and which will not compromise the structural integrity of moveable composite insert 16. In other embodiments, as illustrated in FIG. 7, moveable composite insert 16 lacks apertures 16 b.

In certain embodiments, outer perimeter edge 16 g may have an irregular shape, as illustrated in FIGS. 5B and 5C. The irregular shape of outer perimeter edge 16 g, along with apertures 16 b, may provide an enhanced grip of moveable composite insert 16 to the cured laminate, as will be discussed in greater detail below.

As discussed above, one or more moveable composite inserts 16 may be attached to a composite in a manner which allows the composite to be held in place on a tooling apparatus using the guiding mechanisms described herein. FIG. 6 illustrates a moveable composite insert 16 attached to composite part 2, which is held in position on the surface of tool 4 using bushing 12 and alignment pin 14, according to an embodiment of the present application. Composite part 2, as illustrated in the embodiment of FIG. 6, is a laminate comprising multiple plies 3 a and 3 b. While composite part 2, as illustrated, comprises eight plies, a laminate having any suitable number of plies is contemplated. Moveable composite insert 16 is held in place between plies 3 a and 3 b by chemical and/or physical bonds formed between composite part 2 and surfaces of moveable composite insert 16, including major surfaces 16 e and 16 f.

The chemical and/or physical bond may be formed during curing of composite part 2, and may be enhanced by properly preparing the surface of moveable composite insert 16 prior to the cure operation. For example, the surface of moveable composite insert 16 may be cleaned to remove oils or dirt which may reduce or prevent chemical bonding between the moveable composite insert 16 and composite part 2. In another embodiment, the surface of moveable composite insert 16 may be coated to enhance chemical bonding prior to the cure operation. For example, in some embodiments, an adhesion promoting primer is applied to the surface of moveable composite insert 16. In other embodiments, the surface of moveable composite insert 16 is covered with “B”-staged film adhesive to promote bonding to composite part 2. In yet another embodiment, the surface of moveable composite insert 16 may be roughened, such as, for example by etching, to provide enhanced bonding. Other suitable techniques for enhancing chemical bonding between moveable composite insert 16 and composite part 2 would be readily apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art and may also be employed.

In the embodiments illustrated in FIGS. 5A to 5C, apertures 16 b and/or the irregular shaped outer perimeter edge 16 g may promote the physical bond of composite part 2 to moveable composite insert 16. While not intending to be limited by theory, it is believed that the wet plies of composite part 2 may press through apertures 16 b, so that once cured, composite part 2 physically grips moveable composite insert 16. Apertures 16 b may be formed in any desired configuration which will provide the desired physical bond, and which will not compromise the structural integrity of moveable composite insert 16.

Moveable composite insert 16 may have any desired dimensions. The particular shape and size may be adjusted depending on, for example, the size of the offal in which moveable composite insert 16 will be positioned, and the amount of bonding surface required to hold moveable composite insert 16 in place in the composite. A greater bonding surface area between composite part 2 and moveable composite insert 16 may result in moveable composite insert 16 being held more firmly in place.

Moveable composite insert 16 may include a raised portion 16 c corresponding to a thicker region surrounding opening 16 a, as seen in FIGS. 5A and 6. Raised portion 16 c allows the bearing strength of moveable composite insert 16 to be increased around opening 16 a, while at the same time allowing the outer portion 16 d of moveable composite insert 16 to have a reduced thickness. A reduced thickness of outer portion 16 d will reduce the space between the plies on either side of moveable composite insert 16, and thereby reduce the overall effect of inserting the moveable composite insert 16 on the thickness of the finished composite part 2. This may provide benefits in certain embodiments where it is undesirable to significantly increase the thickness of the composite laminate proximate the composite insert.

Moveable composite insert 16 may be formed using any suitable method. Examples of such methods include machining techniques, such as electric discharge machining (EDM) or metal stamping techniques, both of which are well known in the art.

Moveable composite insert 16 may be made from any suitable material. Examples of suitable materials include stainless steel, spring steel, ceramics, carbon and Teflon.

Moveable composite insert 16 may be attached to composite part 2 using any technique which will result in chemical and/or physical bonding suitable to hold moveable composite insert 16 in place in the composite, while at the same time providing the proper alignment of opening 16 a. For example, as illustrated in the embodiment of FIG. 6, moveable composite insert 16 may be bonded between plies 3 a and 3 b of composite part 2. In this process, holes 28 are formed in wet plies 3 a and 3 b at the position where moveable composite insert 16 is to be inserted. One or more wet plies 3 a are then positioned on tool 4 so that alignment pin bushing 12 is exposed through holes 28. Moveable composite insert 16 is then placed on wet plies 3 a so that opening 16 a is aligned in a desired direction.

The desired direction may depend on a number of factors such as, for example, the size and shape of the tool, the size and shape of the wet composite part, the size and shape of the parts to which the composite part may be subsequently bonded, as well as the relative CTE values for the tool and/or the composite materials. In one exemplary embodiment, longitudinal axis, z_(o), of opening 16 a may be aligned in the direction of the major axis of expansion of composite part 2. In another embodiment, longitudinal axis, z_(o), of opening 16 a may be aligned in the direction of the major axis of expansion of tool 4. In yet other embodiments, where a circular or arched tool is employed, it may be desirable to align opening 16 a along a radius of the circle or in a direction of the curvature of the arch. One of ordinary skill in the art may readily envision additional embodiments in which it would be desirable to align opening 16 a along another axis of expansion. Such additional embodiments fall within the scope of the present application.

Alignment pin 14 may be inserted through opening 16 a into aperture 12 d of alignment pin bushing 12, so that head 14 b lies within opening 16 a, as seen in FIG. 6. In an alternative embodiment, alignment pin 14 may be inserted into alignment pin bushing 12, and then moveable composite insert 16 may be positioned so that head 14 b lies within opening 16 a. As discussed above, head 14 b is fixed in position when shank 14 a is inserted into alignment pin bushing 12, so that head 14 b maintains the alignment of opening 16 a in a desired direction during subsequent cure steps.

After moveable composite insert 16 is positioned on wet plies 3 a, one or more additional plies 3 b are positioned over wet plies 3 a and portions of moveable composite insert 16. Holes 28 in plies 3 b are positioned so as to expose alignment pin 14 and the slotted portion of moveable composite insert 16. The temperature of composite part 2 is then ramped up to the desired cure temperature and moveable composite insert 16 is bonded to composite part 2.

During the cure operation, and the resulting thermal expansion of composite part 2, alignment pin 14 maintains the desired alignment of opening 16 a, since longitudinal axis z_(o) of opening 16 a is aligned in the same direction as longitudinal axis x_(o) of head 14 b when head 14 b is positioned within opening 16 a. Thus, alignment pin 14 acts as a guiding mechanism for controlling the direction of longitudinal axis z_(o) of opening 16 a while allowing moveable composite insert 16 to move along head 14 b during the cure step. In this manner, moveable composite insert 16 may be bonded to composite part 2 so that longitudinal axis z_(o) of opening 16 a is fixed in the desired direction. The orientation of longitudinal axis z_(o) of opening 16 a relative to composite part 2 determines the direction composite part 2 is allowed to move relative to the surface of tool 4 during subsequent thermal expansion.

After moveable composite insert 16 is bonded in place in composite part 2, alignment pin 14 may be replaced by a straight pin 32, as illustrated in the embodiment of FIG. 9, if desired. The head of straight pin 32 is has a decreased length compared to the length, L_(h), of head 14 b of alignment pin 14, which may allow increased room for movement of moveable composite insert 16 on the head of straight pin 32. The increased movement may be desirable during high temperature processing, such as post-curing, where an increased degree of thermal expansion may occur in the tool 4 and/or the composite part 2.

During subsequent thermal cycles, the guiding mechanism, such as, for example, straight pin 32 or alignment pin 14, allows composite part 2 to move along opening 16 a. As discussed above, opening 16 a controls the movement of moveable composite insert 16, and hence the movement of composite part 2, to which moveable composite insert 16 is bonded. In this manner, the relative position of composite part 2 on tool 4 may be maintained along a desired axis of thermal expansion.

FIGS. 8A and 8B illustrate one embodiment of a straight pin 32. In the illustrated embodiment, straight pin 32 comprises a groove 32 c to allow placement of an O-ring 32 e around shank 32 a, similarly as described above for alignment pin 14. Also similar to alignment pin 14, straight pin 32 may include a hole 32 d positioned in the top of head 32 b, the inner surface of which may be threaded so that a slide hammer, or other device, may be screwed into hole 32 d and used to remove straight pin 32 from alignment pin bushing 12. In the embodiment of FIGS. 8A and 8B, shank 32 a of straight pin 32 has a circular cross section formed by a plane intersecting a longitudinal axis y of shank 32 a at right angles. However, straight pin 32 may have any suitably shaped cross section, such as a square, or other polygon shaped, cross section.

Stationary assembly 7, as discussed above with respect to the embodiment of FIG. 2, will now be described in more detail. As illustrated in the embodiment of FIG. 10, stationary assembly 7 may comprise a stationary pin bushing 18, a stationary pin 20 and a stationary composite insert 22.

Stationary composite insert 22 may be similar to moveable composite insert 16 described above, except that opening 22 a of stationary composite insert 22 is designed to accept stationary pin 20 so as to hold stationary composite insert 22 substantially stationary. In the embodiment illustrated in FIG. 10, stationary composite insert 22 has an opening 22 a having approximately the same dimensions as a cross section of stationary pin 20, the cross section being formed by a plane intersecting a longitudinal axis y of stationary pin 20 at right angles. In this manner, stationary composite insert 22 may be held substantially stationary in all directions perpendicular to the longitudinal axis y of stationary pin 20 by positioning the stationary composite insert 22 and stationary pin 20 so that stationary pin 20 extends through opening 22 a.

Diameter, d_(si), of opening 22 a may be formed to be only slightly larger than, the diameter, d_(sp), of the cross section of stationary pin 20, so that stationary pin 20 may fit through opening 22 a in a frictional slip fit arrangement. The relative dimensions of d_(si) and d_(sp) may be adjusted to maintain the desired degree of precision in holding composite part 2 stationary. For example, in embodiments where very high alignment tolerances of composite parts in subsequent bonding is desired, the relative sizes of these dimensions may be adjusted to achieve the desired tolerances. In one embodiment, d_(si) may be formed to be less than about 0.01 inches larger than d_(sp). In another exemplary embodiment, d_(si) may be about 0.001 to about 0.0001 inches larger than d_(sp).

Opening 22 a may have any suitable shape or size which corresponds to the dimensions of stationary pin 20. For example, in the embodiment illustrated in FIG. 10, both opening 22 a and the cross section of stationary pin 20 have a circular shape. In other embodiments, both the cross section of stationary pin 20 and opening 22 a may be square, for example.

As shown in FIG. 11, stationary composite insert 22 comprises a first major surface 22 e, an opposing second major surface (not shown), and an outer perimeter edge 22 g formed between the first and second major surfaces. In the illustrated embodiment, opening 22 a is formed through stationary composite insert 22 along a central axis z_(s). In other embodiments, opening 22 a may be offset from central axis z_(s). In one embodiment, a plurality of apertures 22 b may be formed through stationary composite insert 22, the apertures 22 b being formed between opening 22 a and outer perimeter edge 22 g. Apertures 22 b may be formed in any desired configuration which will provide the necessary physical bond between the composite part and stationary composite insert 22, and which will not compromise the structural integrity of stationary composite insert 22. In another embodiment illustrated in FIG. 10, stationary composite insert 22 lacks apertures 22 b.

Stationary composite insert 22 may be attached to composite structures using any of the techniques described above for attaching moveable composite insert 16 to composite part 2, such as bonding stationary composite insert 22 between plies of a composite part, as described above with reference to FIG. 6. Stationary composite insert 22 may be held in place between the plies of composite part 2 by chemical and/or by physical bonding, in a similar manner to that described above for moveable composite insert 16. The chemical bond may be enhanced by properly preparing the surface of stationary composite insert 22 prior to the cure operation, such as by cleaning the surface of stationary composite insert 22 to remove oils or dirt, and/or by treating the surface of stationary composite insert 22 by chemically etching and/or applying an adhesion promoting primer or other coating, similarly as discussed above for moveable composite insert 16.

The first and/or second major surfaces of stationary composite insert 22 may include a raised portion 22 c surrounding opening 22 a, similar to raised portion 16 c of moveable composite insert 16, as described above with reference to FIG. 5A. This would allow the bearing strength of stationary composite insert 22 to be increased around opening 22 a, while at the same time allowing an outer portion 22 d of stationary composite insert 22 to have a reduced thickness, which may be beneficial for the reasons set forth above in the discussion of moveable composite insert 16.

Stationary composite insert 22 may be formed using any suitable technique, including the techniques described above for making moveable composite insert 16, including machining techniques, such as EDM or metal stamping techniques.

Stationary pin 20, illustrated in the embodiment of FIG. 10, may be any suitable pin which may be used in combination with stationary composite insert 22 to hold composite part 2 stationary. For example, a straight pin 32, having O-ring 32 e and a threaded hole 32 d, described above in connection with FIG. 8, may be employed. In another embodiment, a straight pin without an O-ring and/or a threaded hole 32 d, may be employed. In yet another embodiment, a straight pin having a cross section which is not circular may be employed. For example, a straight pin having a square cross section may be used where opening 22 a of stationary composite insert is square. As described above, the cross sectional dimensions of stationary pin 20 are chosen to provide a frictional slip fit arrangement with opening 22 a of stationary composite insert 22, in order to hold stationary composite insert 22 substantially stationary.

Referring back to FIG. 10, stationary pin bushing 18 may be any suitable bushing which may be employed in combination with stationary pin 20 and stationary composite insert 22 to hold composite part 2 stationary. For example, stationary pin bushing 18 may have an aperture 18 a with a circular shaped cross section. Such bushings having apertures with circular shaped cross sections are well known in the art. In other embodiments, a bushing having a cross section which is not circular may be employed, such as, for example, a bushing having a square cross section. In one embodiment, stationary pin bushing 18 may have an aperture 18 a with a circular shaped cross section, and a groove shaped to accept an O-ring positioned in the inner surface at one end of aperture 18 a, similar to groove 12 g in FIG. 3A. In yet another embodiment, the bushings described above with reference to FIGS. 3A to 3E may be employed as the stationary pin bushing.

Stationary pin bushing 18 may be chosen so as to have an aperture 18 a with dimensions which will provide a frictional slip fit relationship with stationary pin 20. For example, in the embodiment of FIG. 10, the diameter d_(b) of aperture 18 a may be chosen to be slightly larger than diameter d_(sp) of stationary pin 20. The relative dimensions of aperture 18 a, and the diameter of stationary pin 20 may be adjusted to achieve any desired tolerances, including a high tolerance slip fit arrangement. For example, d_(b) may be formed to be less than about 0.01 inches larger than d_(sp). In another exemplary embodiment, d_(b) may be about 0.001 to about 0.0001 inches larger than d_(sp).

The stationary assemblies of the present application, including stationary composite insert 22, stationary pin 20, and stationary pin bushing 18 may be made from any suitable material. Examples of suitable materials include stainless steel, spring steel, ceramics, carbon and Teflon.

The individual parts of both the moveable and stationary assemblies may be made from the same or different materials. For example, the moveable composite insert 16 may comprise a ceramic material while the alignment pin 14 and/or the alignment pin bushing 12 may comprise steel.

As discussed above, various combinations of moveable and stationary assemblies may be employed to control the direction of thermal expansion during fabrication of a composite part. During thermal processing, the composite part is held stationary relative to the surface of the tool at one or more stationary positions of the composite part, while allowing the composite part to move in a desired direction of thermal expansion relative to the surface of the tool at one or more moveable positions of the composite part. For example, as discussed above with reference to FIG. 1, by positioning one or more stationary assemblies at stationary position 8 and one or more moveable assemblies at moveable position 6, composite part 2 may be allowed to expand from stationary position 8 toward movable position 6, along the major axis of expansion z.

The arrangement of the moveable and stationary assemblies will vary depending on the shape and size of the composite part. For example, if the part has a “V” shape, as illustrated in FIG. 12, it may be desirable to position a stationary assembly 7 at the bottom of the “V” and a moveable assembly 5 at the top of each branch of the “V,” as shown in FIG. 12. In this manner the bottom of the “V” is held stationary, while movement at the top of each branch of the “V” is controlled so that thermal expansion occurs along the r and s axes.

Yet another embodiment is illustrated in FIG. 13, which shows a cross section of a tool having planar portions 4 a, with a pocket 4 b formed therein, for forming a three dimensional composite part 2. In this embodiment, it may be desirable to position moveable assemblies 5 at either end of composite part 2, and a stationary assembly 7 in the pocket area, as shown, in order to allow for thermal expansion from the pocket toward either end of composite part 2 during thermal processing. One of ordinary skill in the art would readily envision yet other possible configurations of moveable and stationary assemblies to effectively control the direction of thermal expansion of composite parts.

In embodiments where two or more composite parts of a composite assembly are being bonded together, the direction of thermal expansion may be controlled so that the two or more composite parts expand in the same direction and/or along the same axis of expansion, allowing for improved alignment tolerances. For example, as illustrated in FIG. 14, a composite part 34 may be placed on composite part 2. Moveable composite insert 16 and stationary composite insert 22 have been attached to composite part 34 at moveable position 6 and stationary position 8, respectively. In this arrangement, both composite part 2 and composite part 34 are allowed to thermally expand along the same axis of expansion and in the same direction relative to stationary position 8. It is believed that controlling the relative movement of the composite parts with respect to each other and/or with respect to the surface of tool 4 may result in improved alignment tolerances compared to bonding processes where relative movements due to thermal expansion are not similarly controlled.

FIG. 15 illustrates another embodiment where two or more composite parts of a composite assembly are bonded together. In this embodiment, one or more moveable assemblies 5 and one or more stationary assemblies 7 may be used to control the direction of thermal expansion of the composite parts, similarly as discussed above in the embodiment of FIG. 2, except that the alignment pin bushings 12 and stationary pin bushings 18 are positioned in composite part 2, rather than in the surface of tool 4. In the embodiment of FIG. 15, alignment pin bushing 12 and stationary pin bushing 18 may be positioned in composite part 2 by, for example, drilling a hole in the already cured composite part 2, or alternatively by bonding the alignment pin bushing 12 and stationary pin bushing 18 into composite part 2 during the cure operation. One or more moveable composite inserts 16 and stationary composite inserts 22 may be attached to composite part 34. Composite part 34 may then be held in position on composite part 2 using pins, such as straight pin 32 and stationary pin 20, as illustrated in the embodiment of FIG. 15. In this manner, the desired alignment of composite part 34 with composite part 2 may be accomplished. This embodiment may be useful in situations where the tooling equipment, such as tool 4 described above, has not been fitted for bushings, such as alignment pin bushings 12 and/or stationary pin bushings 18.

Although this disclosure has been described in terms of certain preferred embodiments, other embodiments apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art, including embodiments that do not provide all of the features and advantages set forth herein, are also within the scope of this disclosure. Accordingly, the scope of the present disclosure is defined only by reference to the appended claims and equivalents thereof. 

1. A system for controlling the direction of thermal expansion of a composite part during thermal processing, the system comprising: at least one guiding mechanism capable of being attached to a surface of a tool for fabricating composites; and at least one moveable composite insert capable of being attached to the composite part and having an opening for receiving the at least one guiding mechanism; the opening having a configuration capable of controlling movement of the composite insert in a controlled manner when the guiding mechanism is received by the opening.
 2. The system of claim 1, wherein the configuration of the opening is substantially elongated such that movement of the composite insert is controlled to be a substantially back and forth movement.
 3. The system of claim 1, wherein the configuration of the opening is substantially elongated along an axis of expansion of the composite part to which the moveable composite insert is capable of being attached.
 4. The system of claim 1, comprising a plurality of the guiding mechanisms and a corresponding plurality of the moveable composite inserts.
 5. The system of claim 1, wherein the at least one guiding mechanism comprises an alignment pin having a head and a shank, the shank having a non-circular cross section formed in a plane intersecting a longitudinal axis of the shank at right angles, the head having a longitudinal axis which is perpendicular to the longitudinal axis of the shank.
 6. The system of claim 5, wherein the opening of the at least one moveable composite insert is a slot-shaped opening, the slot shaped opening being sized to fit around the head of the at least one alignment pin so that a longitudinal axis of the slot is aligned in the same direction as the longitudinal axis of the head of the at least one alignment pin when the head is positioned within the opening.
 7. The system of claim 6, further comprising at least one alignment pin bushing capable of accepting the shank of the at least one alignment pin in a manner which allows a longitudinal axis of the head to be fixed in a desired direction when the shank is inserted into the at least one alignment pin bushing.
 8. The system of claim 7, wherein the alignment pin bushing is positioned in the surface of the tool for fabricating composites, the tool having a major axis of expansion defined by the direction of greatest thermal expansion of the surface of the tool when the tool is heated, the alignment pin bushing being positioned in a manner which allows the longitudinal axis of the head of the alignment pin to be aligned in the same direction as the major axis of expansion of the tool when the shank of the alignment pin is inserted into the at least one alignment pin bushing.
 9. The system of claim 7, wherein the alignment pin bushing is capable of accepting a shank of a second pin in place of the shank of the alignment pin, the shank of the second pin having a circular cross section formed by a plane intersecting a longitudinal axis of the shank of the second pin at right angles.
 10. The system of claim 9, wherein the alignment pin bushing is capable of accepting both the shank of the alignment pin and the shank of the second pin in a frictional slip fit arrangement.
 11. The system of claim 1, further comprising: at least one stationary pin having a head and a shank; and at least one stationary composite insert having an opening capable of receiving the head of the at least one stationary pin, the stationary composite insert opening having approximately the same dimensions as a cross section formed by a plane intersecting a longitudinal axis of the head of the at least one stationary pin at right angles, so that the stationary composite insert opening may be inserted on the head of the stationary pin to hold the at least one stationary composite insert substantially stationary in all directions perpendicular to the longitudinal axis of the head of the at least one stationary pin.
 12. The system of claim 11, further comprising at least one stationary pin bushing capable of accepting the shank of the at least one stationary pin.
 13. An aircraft composite part comprising: a composite material; and one or more composite inserts attached to the composite material, the one or more composite inserts comprising a first major surface, an opposing second major surface, and an outer perimeter edge formed between the first and second major surfaces; and an opening formed through the composite insert between the first and second major surfaces.
 14. The aircraft composite part of claim 13, wherein the aircraft composite part is an unfinished part which further comprises an offal, the one or more composite inserts being attached to the offal.
 15. The aircraft composite part of claim 13, wherein the one or more composite inserts comprise at least one moveable composite insert and at least one stationary composite insert. 16-21. (canceled) 